Here I am again, watching for the second time, The Next Great American Band episode #3. Second you ask? Yes, I attended the live taping, and am now watching the episode on television 2 days later. Let's get started with my band reviews. These ten made the cut and are in the show next week:
Sixwire
Again, they nailed it. The cover was solid, and the original even better. These guys have the best vocal arrangements in the group, and appear to be the most seasoned, mature musicians of the bunch. Gotta Get Away is ready today for radio play. A catchy hook, and well executed, it works both live and on the radio. Great tune. The cover was a touch slow though, and while it's an incredible song, I hope it doesn't hurt them being first. It wasn't very memorable, in spite of it's incredible execution. I do agree with everything the judges said, they were right on (as usual, although this episode there were a couple of things I took issue with - not including the regular Light of Doom oversights from them.)
One other thing I immediately noticed was the drastic difference in the mix between the live show and the TV episode. The drums were way hotter live, and could have been brought up a touch for TV.
Tre's Bien
The original was ok. In the interest of honesty and fairness, I'm just not a fan. The shtick works, they have found a niche, but the question is, does it have longevity? I liked the energy the lead singer brought to the stage. I actually thought they did the cover fairly well, but their style is really suited for this night. Performance wise, it's a bit raw, and that does add an edge, but Dicko was right, they needed a bit more practice. Again, the judges were all right. Fun, but a bit underplayed from a technical standpoint.
Franklin Bridge
For as good as these guys are, they don't listen. Perhaps they should, the judges are all very successful. The unsolved problem? Too complicated. And quite frankly, the original was boring until it built up, but it went from about 10 to 100 in less than a fill, and there was no real build up to the pay off. They needed some work in that regard. Honestly disappointed - especially after last week. As a side note, their original they performed twice due to a technical difficulty. However, they performed it identically both times.
The judges, again were right now. Now, can Franklin Bridge pay attention?
The Clark Brothers
These guys are really talented. I've said that before. Country time is a good tune, but it looses it's forward momentum too soon due to the lack of drums and bass. The cover, a ballad called "Country Comfort" was very well suited for them, but again, it's usually the bands with higher energy levels and better known songs that last. Live, the song went over really, really well. It was great to give my ears a break and have something really nice to listen to. I'm really glad to see them in this thus far, and hope they last.
The judges, again, right on.
Light of Doom
"We are gonna rock tonight,
Heads are gonna roll tonight"
How original. How quaint. I remember what I thought rock/metal was like when I was 13, and yep, that's it, right there.
I understand why people like these guys. It's the "Wow, I wish I was in a metal band when I was little" factor. But there is a reality here that keeps being overlooked. Next time, if you can, don't look at them, just listen. There is NO WAY that you can say these guys are nearly as good as any of the other bands. Vocally, they are weak, rhythmically, they are all over the place. Now, open your eyes and you see a bunch of kids and think, "Wow, they are really good, for being pre-pubescent boys." But this isn't "The Next Great American Kid" contest. I'm so disappointed with Sheila E. in particular. Yes, they rock, but they also need improvement to GET to the level that the rest of the bands are at. And Dicko was absolutely right, it feels completely unoriginal, and a gimmick made for TV. The parents should be proud, but at what cost to their kids?
Dot Dot Dot
A much improved performance. Far easier to watch and musical. Vocally it was ok, the guitar performances were good - and playing to a loop helps their rhythm and timing. As a keyboard player who attended Berklee College of Music and studied music synthesis, I thought the keys were pretty good too - not very original though. And they are the only band using a Korg, so it's not like they are grabbing some backline keyboard, spending a little more time on your sound selection and programming would bring a lot to their sound.
The cover was way, way bigger live. the guitars were too far back in the mix on TV to get an impression of how big it actually got. I didn't care for this band originally, but they are growing on me - if they keep going in the direction they are going.
The judges, again, were right on here.
Cliff Wagner and the Old No. 7
I felt they were a little better last week. However, one thing these guys really have going for them is their background/intro videos. They seem to have great personalities, and it's endearing. So, you get to like the guys, therefore wanting them to do well. The original got old quickly to me. But keep in mind, while I appreciate the musicality and technical ability of really good blue grass players, I'm not a fan of the style.
The cover was decent, and entertaining, but I honestly don't think the voters are going to embrace them simply on their personalities. It's like the age old answer to "Is she good looking?" "Umm... she has a great personality."
Again, I thought the judges were right on. They are fun. However, what can they do to improve and have a better chance of staying in?
The Muggs
I love the sound of these guys, but vocally, they need so, so much work. Honestly, I was most disappointed in their performance tonight than any other. I had high expectations. I'm sitting here listening to the jam at the end of the original, and I'm loving it. It's awesome. But the vocals are so distracting. His guitars are excellent though.
Unfortunately, the cover wasn't very well executed either. It's almost like they didn't have enough rehearsal time. I have the blues after this...
And, and and... never argue with, let alone boo the judges from the stage. This is key - LISTEN to the judges.
Rocket
Another style I really don't care for. But again, this is a style people do like. It sounds a lot better on TV actually. But, but... they are weaker rhythmically, and definitely vocally. Hopefully, again, they will listen to the judges. There's a lot of potential to this band, really. But they just have so much work to do.
The comment from the lead singer - "I am who I am" is fine and it resonates with kids with identity crisis. BUT, please, hone your craft. You should always strive to be better.
Denver & the Mile High Orchestra
The original was great - although the chorus sounds unfinished. They nailed it.
I have three points to make.
1. There is a reason they closed the show with these guys. It was awesome. Last week they opened the show.
2.They were bigger live. I wish it translated to TV better. It was huge when the horns stopped, then slammed into the closing phrase. And Sheila E. asked if she could play percussion with them if they ever needed one. That got cut from the show.
3. Dicko was wrong about the tempo change on the cover. Did you notice? He asked why they slowed it down, and Sheila started to contradict him. "No, No they didn't." It was cut time. And it was awesome that way.
The Mile High Orchestra still has my vote, of course, but I've changed my opinion about some of the other bands. It just goes to show that you can't formulate your opinions based on one show. Maybe next time I'll be complimenting Light of Doom... uh... no.